Artforum by César Aira

I recently saw a list of anticipated book releases in the US, and on it was a collection of five novels from the Argentinian writer, César Aira. I’d never heard of Aira, but when I looked him up I was surprised to see that he’s published over 100 novels. Curious, I found one of his novels, Artforum, at the library.
It is 82 pages, and the entire novel is a set of episodes centered around the narrator’s obsession with the magazine Artforum. Experimental, surrealist, and absurd, the book challenges what we think narrative fiction is, or should be. It reminds me of Richard Brautigan’s short work, or perhaps Murakami.
In the first chapter, a stack of books left under an open window get wet when it rains, and when the narrator finds them, the Artforum magazine has morphed into a glowing ball of light. In another, the narrator frets over his delayed subscription to Artforum. In another, he discovers a stack of Artforum back issues in a used bookstore, and it seems to be one of the greatest things to ever happen to him.
What is most weird about these stories isn’t how bizarre the narrator’s obsession is. It actually seems quite normal (save the glowing ball of light). We probably all have similarly weird obsessions and proclivities. People are weird. But you don’t see it written about much, at least not for 82 pages.
Part of Aira’s avant-garde writing method is what he calls la fuga hacia adelante, or “the flight forward,” in which he intentionally intentionally writes himself into corners, but only allows himself to write his way forward out of them. He can never go back and edit, no matter how problematic or absurd the plot has become. He sees it as more like an improvisational performance art than the traditional method of writing and revising.
It’s a fascinating approach. I’m not ready to yet deliver a verdict on whether or not it delivers on his belief that preserving imperfections maintains the vitality in the work. But I love that this exists and that there are writers (or at least one writer) like Aira.
I did order Five, Aira’s newly published collection of novellas. We’ll see how those go.
The Castle: Adventures in a World of Unraveling Men by Jon Ronson

Jon Ronson could be called an expert in hanging with crazy people. The author of Them: Adventures with Extremists and The Men Who Stare at Goats, Ronson has a gift for spending time with oddballs, fanatics, eccentrics, secret society members, conspiracy theorists and cultists. And getting them to talk.
Many of these people are harmless. But sometimes there’s also a darkness to them. And sometimes, if they can accumulate any kind of power, they’re not harmless anymore.
The Castle is in the tradition of books that skim that fine edge, alongside books like Gun Guys (are they just hobbyists or are they to blame for school shootings?) and Confederates in the Attic (are they just Civil War LARPers or are they hardcore racists?). It also reminded me of Masters of Atlantis, for the certitude with which delusional people can discuss their ideas.
At the center is Chris Mark, a man who owns a castle near Woodstock, Connecticut, and dreams of making a show called “101 Princesses,” a sort of pornographic reality show. Ronson investigates him and uncovers layers of abuse allegations and general weirdness surrounding Mark.
In the most interesting part of the book, he then spirals outward into the manosphere, groups of leftbehinds, and pariahs from public scandals. Armie Hammer appears. Various influencers and podcasters. He has a section on ICE, which recruits from communities of adrift men seeking purpose, promising them a career where they can dress up like soldiers and wield power.
These men are often hurt in a way that social norms don’t allow them to express. They’re often desperate to regain footing or find a community. And so they’re susceptible to fringe movements, cult-like groups, social media rabbit holes, conspiracy theories. In other words, Jon Ronson’s world.
But what Ronson finds is that his “world” has gotten very crowded lately. The modern cocktail of technology, media, politics and loneliness makes it easy for anyone’s hurt to mutate into an entire worldview. Educated people aren’t immune. Nor are elected officials. Financial wealth doesn’t shield you (it may even make you more prone).
From a post on Ronson’s Substack:
“…these are stories about why some men are feeling tossed around in a sea of conflicting ideologies about what being a man actually means – and are, as a result, becoming detached from reality, behaving like separatists, creating a new era of disinhibition. It’s a book about how there are suddenly lots of things that men have been used to doing that they can’t do any more – and are, as a consequence, unraveling, creating fake realities, strange worlds for themselves inside their homes and castles…”
I know at least one person, an old college friend, who has gone down the dark alley of conspiracy theories and manosphere anger. His failed marriage left him angry at women, then the rest of the world. He now occasionally texts me to pick political fights for no apparent reason other than something got him riled up and he wants to spar. It’s unsettling, but mostly it’s sad.
What stayed with me from The Castle isn’t Chris Mark’s literal castle, but an image of a metaphorical castle. We talk about living in bubbles, but living in a castle is worse. It’s a newer, more malicious kind of bubble, with ramparts and defensive weaponry. Meant to keep out the enemy—that is, the ideas that challenge our beliefs.
We all do this, to a certain degree, by our media and friend choices. And we let it be done to us, by the algorithms that curate our feeds. Execs can do it by surrounding themselves with yes-men, or creating a culture where any kind of dissent is punished. These all create a kind of fortress for thought, where nothing gets in that might pop the “unreality field.”
I think of Tim Urban’s writings and Alan Jacobs’ How to Think. Both of those authors write about the struggle to have a mind that maintains necessary gates, not letting everything into our attention or our consideration, but doesn’t completely shut them and leave our current beliefs unchallenged. The key, I think, is to create an open castle (to stick with that metaphor), with a guard who allows in ideas that continually shape and challenge our beliefs, but also keeps out the junk. This is one of the great challenges of modern life.
Overall, The Castle is interesting. Chris Mark is a strange, possibly dangerous man. But I didn’t find his story as compelling as the psychology he represents. A man in his castle. Lonely, deluded, but believing to his core that he’s on to something, with nobody around to tell him it’s a bad idea.
I might have preferred a series of essays, each approaching this societal challenge through a different story. That would have allowed Ronson to stray farther into the dark nooks and shed light on all the contributing psychologies. In the end, it felt like the tie to the Chris Mark narrative was more of a hindrance to what the book could have been.
Perfect Pitch by Jon Steel

Jon Steel is the legendary strategist behind the “Got Milk?” campaign, an integral part of the rise of the ad agency Goodby, Silverstein & Partners in the 1990s, and one of the most influential figures in the popularization of account planning (strategy) in the US.
Account planning started as a practice in the UK in the 1960s, but wasn’t imported to the US until decades later. US agencies had research departments, but account planners—also known as strategists—are much more integrated into the full process of developing an ad campaign. They conduct consumer research, then write the creative brief based on consumer insights and competitive positioning. While research might uncover a fact, planners ask “So what?” And they typically remain involved in the process, representing the voice of the consumer as the ad campaign is developed.
Steel’s 1998 book, Truth, Lies and Advertising, was foundational in popularizing the practice of account planning in the US.
Perfect Pitch is focused on pitching new business. Less widely read, it is just as good. I assigned it as part of my integrated campaigns class, where students work with (and pitch work to) real clients.
Pitching new business is something you learn on the job. It is high pressure and high stakes, often with a lot of money on the line. Pitches can be huge career accelerators for the winners, and they can drain the energy and resources from the losers (both the agencies and the individuals).
I’ve been on both sides of the table—agency and client—in new business pitches. I’ve won, lost, and delivered news to agencies that have won or lost. I’ve seen pitch teams work together like the 1995-96 Chicago Bulls and others look more like the Bad News Bears.
Oftentimes, the performance of the team has little correlation with the quality of their thinking. It’s usually about communication (isn’t everything?), chemistry, discipline and experience. And, as Steel points out, just plain ol’ likability.
Perfect Pitch is comprehensive. Steel covers story structure and the framing of your idea, the competitive positioning of your pitch (and agency), team dynamics, preparation, building the deck, presentation advice, and much more.
This is a book that’s about new business, but anyone who pitches work at any level could learn a lot from it. It’s a good read too, full of interesting stories told in a conversational, down-to-earth style. I imagine many new business pitches since 2006 have been put over the top because a team read and applied the advice Steel gives in this classic.
The Jackal: The Rise and Fall of Carlos, the World’s First Super-Terrorist by Joby Warrick

I went into Joby Warrick’s book about Carlos the Jackal expecting a story with a little more electricity. Carlos was a Venezuelan revolutionary who became an international fugitive, created an image of glamor, and for a time seemed to be everywhere. Before Osama bin Laden, Carlos was the name most synonymous with international terrorism. He was the world’s first celebrity terrorist.
What the book lacks is also the point of the book: the closer Warrick takes us to Carlos, the less interesting he becomes. There’s something fascinating about a revolutionary whose beliefs drive him to extremes. But early in his career, Carlos shed whatever ideology he once possessed and became a terrorist for hire. His cause was himself. His chief asset was his willingness to be brutal, and he was happy to sell that talent to whoever could use it.
Warrick quietly deflates the mythology Carlos built around himself. The super-terrorist is overweight, frequently vain, sometimes bumbling, and considerably less capable than his reputation suggested. By the end, the aging Carlos is getting plastic surgery and dealing with emasculating body issues. It gave me an idea for a short story about an old terrorist in an assisted care facility, bragging to whoever would listen in the common room about what a big deal he used to be, how he used to be on magazine covers, how women would throw themselves at him. “The Terrorist at Rest,” I would call it.
Unfortunately, demythologizing Carlos also has the effect of demythologizing his story. Large stretches of the book follow him as he moves from country to country, finds new patrons, wears out his welcome, and shops his particular talents around. It’s interesting historically, but sometimes a little dull. Because Carlos didn’t have much of a central purpose beyond perpetuating his own career, there isn’t much of a central narrative pulling the story forward because.
The book is much more interesting when focused on the operational stuff: the terrorist attacks themselves, the near-captures, and especially the intelligence work that eventually closes the net around Carlos. The scenes of agents tracking him have the tension of a good espionage novel. There’s an exciting stretch involving an American operative from Texas surveilling Carlos in Khartoum, something that feels like a Bourne film.
I liked Warrick’s Black Flags, about the rise of ISIS. And I don’t think the problem here is his writing. The book’s weakness may be because Warrick accomplishes what he set out to do. He strips away the legend and leaves us with the man. It turns out the man just isn’t as interesting as the legend.
The Word Pretty by Elisa Gabbert

I first got into Elisa Gabbert through The Unreality of Memory, her 2020 collection of essays, and really liked her 2024 follow-up, Any Person Is the Only Self. The Word Pretty is from 2018.
Reading backwards, you can see the development of her approach to essays. She uses criticism of books, movies, and television and other arts to springboard into philosophical questions like memory, identity, narrative, language. In this collection alone, we find Gone with the Wind, The House of Mirth, Mansfield Park, Howard Zinn, James Salter, Jenny Diski, Jo Ann Beard, MasterChef Junior, Kate Zambreno, Magda Szabó. Some I knew, some who were new to me. High and low, canonical and disposable, all thrown into the same hopper.
I’ve been introduced to more than one great artist by Gabbert. W.G. Sebald, to name a favorite. I have a Sylvia Plath book on my nightstand because of Gabbert. I’ve been eyeing some James Salter.
But because she uses it as a door into something bigger, once you’re through the door, it doesn’t much matter how you got there. Even if I’m not interested in the creative work at hand, I’ll hang to see where she goes with it.
In The Word Pretty, a piece ostensibly about another writer turns into an essay about keeping a notebook. An observation about Homer’s “wine-dark sea” leads to thoughts about how language shapes our perception of color. Writers in translation expands into the idea that everything is, in some sense, translated: if not through language, then through our senses.
Elsewhere she writes about crying, dream logic, aphorisms, how sunglasses disrupt connection. The relationship between change—even superficial—and happiness.
My favorite essay, “The Art of the Paragraph,” is about the art of the transition between paragraphs, the poetic leaps that deft writers can make from one to the next. How the connections can be surprising and enlightening, the juxtaposition of ideas creating something new.
It also provides a useful way of thinking about Gabbert’s work overall, the way she links one topic with the next. Her essays create a kind of latticework of ideas. Artwork to observation to larger idea, to a different artwork, to a personal memory, to a philosophical idea, which somehow circles back around. The individual nodes are interesting, but the pathways between them are more interesting.
These are small essays, six to ten pages, but they’re nonetheless thoughtful and provocative. Gabbert is a poet as well as an essayist. Maybe that’s why she seems comfortable leaving space between ideas and trusting that the reader will make the leap.
I think she’s gotten better at this since The Word Pretty. The Unreality of Memory and Any Person Is the Only Self feel more fully realized, with more interesting starting points. But reading this earlier collection makes the progression interesting. And the pleasure of bouncing around Gabbert’s head with her is as strong here as it is in her later books.
London Falling by Patrick Radden Keefe and People Who Eat Darkness by Richard Lloyd Parry

I read these two books back-to-back. That coincidence may not be enough reason to lump them together in a review, but they’re intertwined in my mind, they reflected off each other as I read, and they overlap in uncanny ways.
London Falling is receiving a decent amount of press, just by being the latest from Patrick Radden Keefe, author of Say Nothing and Empire of Pain. People Who Eat Darkness is a 2010 release that I found on a Best True Crime list.
Both books are harrowing, especially for a parent. They involve cases of young adults caught in nihilistic corners of global capitalism, and of families desperately trying to understand the dark compartments their children have fallen into. Both are brutal in the end, leaving you feeling that the real villains might be the systems themselves.
In London Falling, a 19-year-old boy, Zac Brettler, falls to his death from the fifth floor of a luxury apartment on the River Thames in 2019. Initially ruled a suicide, the investigation begins to unveil a web of lies upon lies, false identities, and a young man who was in way over his head.
It’s also the story of how London became a global center for organized crime after the collapse of the Soviet Union, where a deluge of shady characters, dark money, and anonymity merged in a way that made identities malleable. Movers and shakers and con men all jockeyed for opportunities with high rewards and very high risks.
With his impeccable skill at storytelling, Keefe spools out the story of how that seemingly normal 19-year-old boy took his shot and ultimately lost.
People Who Eat Darkness is about the 2000 disappearance of Lucie Blackman, a 20-year-old British woman who worked in one of Tokyo’s hostess clubs. The hostess club scene is complicated and often confusing to Westerners. It seems akin to prostitution, but is usually described as men paying for a woman to sit, socialize, pour drinks, and feed their egos.
Lucie worked at one of these clubs, which also encouraged its hostesses to have dinner with the men outside the bars for higher pay. Then one weekend, she went to meet a client and never came back. What unfolded after that was a family’s desperate attempt to overcome what they saw as incompetence and apathy by the local police and find their daughter.
Without giving many more specifics away, I’ll just say that People Who Eat Darkness is like a series of trap doors that open under you, each roiling your stomach. It’s the most unnerving book I’ve read in a while, and has a kind of seediness and disorienting cultural paradoxes that make you feel lost and helpless, even as the reader.
Both of these books are worthwhile true crime reads. They’re about kids being drawn into worlds where identity, attention, and access become commodities in predatory economies. Zac and Lucie entered into shadowy settings that were no doubt exciting and new, but that also hid the full extent of their danger.
I continue to marvel at Keefe’s storytelling ability, though the story he had to work with in London Falling isn’t as good as Say Nothing. Parry succeeds in causing more of a visceral reaction, though his writing often feels more straightforward, even procedural.
I also think reading these books as a parent brings a certain kind of fear to the page. They’re stories of kids falling into traps that must, from the parents’ perspective, feel random and unfair. Even though I had less sympathy for Zac than Lucie, it’s hard not to have all the sympathy for the parents. They loved and cared as parents do. They warned their kids of the big bad wolves. In the end, it must have felt like the whole world was the big bad wolf.
Presenting to Win by Jerry Weissman

Weissman calls them MEGO moments: My Eyes Glaze Over. A presentation that is too long, too complicated, too boring, too irrelevant. The kind that makes you ponder what sins you’ve committed to find yourself there. The sixth level of hell, if I remember correctly, is where you’re forced to sit through bad business presentations until kingdom come.
Presenting is not easy, to be sure. I’ve presented to teams of executives, clients, bosses, students, one-on-one to CEOs, on video to an entire company, and onstage at conferences. Some presentations were good. Some were bad. I’ve done it a lot, and I still don’t find it particularly easy—though I have gotten used to the game-time jitters.
In my experience, building a presentation and delivering one are two different skills. The first is about planning: constructing the narrative, designing the slides and rehearsing. The second is the actual delivery. The performance.
Presenting to Win is mostly about the first part: figuring out the flow, what to keep in and what to leave out, how to design slides, when to use infographics and what to do about transitions. It’s a practical, thorough book and a great foundation for people entering the corporate world. Weissman covers, among other things, 16 flow structures, 7 opening “gambits” and 12 internal linking techniques.
The book does feel pretty corporate in its case studies, its writing and, particularly, the MBA-ese of some of its scripted presentation bits. And I think it has a few MEGO moments of its own. But not too many.
I honestly think that to be a great presenter, you need an intuitive knack for storytelling and a decent EQ. You need to understand how to build tension and resolution, as you would in any compelling narrative. And you need to know what’s going to land with your audience. Ideally, you can read the room and adjust on the fly. But that should also be part of your preparation: anticipating different reactions and thinking through the contingencies.
Presenting to Win may get you 70 percent of the way there. It will help you build your presentation and avoid most of the major mistakes that can make one bad, such as treating it as an opportunity to show off your knowledge rather than a way to move your audience from Point A to Point B. It’s a great foundation.
Will it make you a great presenter? Probably not. That requires a lot of practice, coaching and time spent watching other great presenters. As we’ve seen with TED Talks, anyone can follow a format and mimic a style. But making a presentation truly compelling and authentic is a whole other ball of wax.
If you’re in a career where presentations are a major part of the business, there are more advanced books that build on the fundamentals in Presenting to Win. For advertising, I’d recommend Jon Steel’s Perfect Pitch and Peter Coughter’s The Art of the Pitch. For presenting creative work specifically, try Ben Levy’s Stop Reading Slides.
As someone who teaches presentation skills in some of my classes—and who has sat through hundreds of MEGO presentations—I believe the corporate world would be a much better place if everyone read and followed what Weissman lays out in this book. It may not be God’s work, but preventing MEGO moments wherever they occur is a worthy crusade.
Creative Hacks by James Douglas Cooper

I’m a sucker for these kinds of books. Most of the classes I teach are on creative advertising or creativity in general, so this topic is very relevant and familiar.
Cooper is a seasoned advertising creative, songwriter, photographer, filmmaker, etc., and the advice he gives feels lived-in and well-earned. I don’t love that he calls them “hacks,” which sounds like cheats. I prefer the word “tools,” but tomayto—tomahto.
Overall, I dig the format of this book. It’s a list of 101 hacks, each with a short description. Easy to buzz through or drop into for a few minutes. If you’re creatively blocked, flipping through it will almost certainly give you something to try.
I like that Cooper goes from tactical to more philosophical or even holistic advice. Creativity isn’t just about knowing techniques for coming up with ideas. It’s also affected by your mood, time of day, environment, etc. One of the things I emphasize to my students is that they need to study themselves, experiment and pay attention to when and why they’re at their best. So advice like “Cultivate a Peaceful Life,” “Have Really, Really Good Sleep” or “Walk Your Dog,” while not as directly tied to the work as something like “Don’t Edit As You Go,” is still very relevant. And those creative life bits of advice can make the biggest difference in the long run.
I’ve heard a lot of this advice before and even teach much of it, but it’s still good to hear it in a different form, with different words. It helps me bring new angles into the classroom in the never-ending search to find what clicks for the students.
If I wanted to pick a nit, I would say that the advice is ordered a little randomly. But neatly shelving it into sections or chapters might kill the vibe of the book. It’s more chill than that.
Put this book on your shelf next to Rick Rubin’s The Creative Act and your deck of Oblique Strategies. Dip in when you need a creative boost. There’s good stuff here. If you have a creative practice, this will give you 101 ways/hacks/tools to experiment, tweak and grow.
This is Strategy by Seth Godin

Strategy is about making decisions. About focus. About winnowing away all the options and designing the best way forward. Basically everything that this book is not.
There are plenty of How To books on strategy, so no need for Godin to write another. And I’m generally a fan of Godin. He dropped a comment or re-shared something from the blog my buddy Greg and I were writing years ago, and it was like business Ram Dass had dropped in. But I found this book to be lazy and arrogant. I really didn’t want to, and I’m kind of bummed that that’s where I landed.
First of all, the book is a list of “riffs,” he calls them. On the first page, we get this strategy poem:
Traction is progress.
Help others get to where they’re going.
Big problems require small solutions.
The work is easier if you can see where you’re headed.
Change creates tension.
Better is possible.
Actually, before we get to the first page, on the back of the book, is this:

Even as section titles, or aphorisms, or business koans, these are bad. Why, as a best-selling marketing guru, would you put this on the back of your book?
The whole book is like this. 297 numbered, titled riffs, a few paragraphs each. Uneven, disorganized, jumping from tools to anecdotes to business advice. It’s like the most annoying kind of strategist. One who doesn’t distill but just reframes, analogizes, and asks supposedly provocative questions that are too obtuse to be helpful.
The book is not devoid of insights, to be sure. As an example, “190. Who benefits?” (terrible name) is about the beneficiaries—and therefore biggest supporters—of entrenched systems. 191 outlines the “system traps” defined by Donella Meadows, author of Thinking in Systems. Great, maybe file those under “Change Management” or put them in a chapter on how systems can work for or against us. But instead, at 192, we get a list of the manipulation techniques of Robert Moses.
This is not strategy. It doesn’t exemplify the actual craft of strategy. It’s a brain dump. If you told me it was the direct transcription of voice memos that Godin left himself on his travels between speaking engagements and consulting gigs, I would say that tracks with what’s here.
But why? Where is the editor? Where is the effort to turn these draft blog posts into something coherent? There’s no benefit to the reader in the jazz-cafe style.
Godin tells us upfront how to use this book. He tells us his narrative is “recursive and elliptical.” That “it’s okay to skip the parts that don’t resonate (yet). Jump ahead, then loop back. Stick with it…”
He tells us to form a group and set up a weekly zoom call. To highlight what jumps out to us and discuss it. “Every riff here is numbered, to make it easy to refer to sections worth discussing.” Yeah, so do page numbers.
The whole premise of this book and the tone upfront suggests that he is dumping random brilliance on us and it’s up to us to pan it for gold flakes. He even, after telling us how to use this book, writes, “Thanks for doing the work.”
I’m not allergic to work. And good strategy is hard work. But I want the author—best-selling celebrity or otherwise—to hold up their end of the bargain. To do their work.
A Place Both Wonderful and Strange: The Extraordinary Untold History of Twin Peaks by Scott Meslow

I loved this book so much. It dropped me back into the world of Twin Peaks, a place I hadn’t visited in a while, and almost immediately made me want to go back. I’m now about fifteen episodes into a rewatch of the original series. It’s my happy place. A very weird, dark happy place.
I’m not sure a “casual” Twin Peaks fan exists. To have the full picture of the show, you have to make the entire pilgrimage. That includes 29 episodes of the original series, the very difficult Fire Walk With Me film, and then 18 episodes of The Return. Nearly 45 hours total. You’d have to be a real weirdo to watch all that if you’re not a true fan. And if you’re not a fan, I’m not sure why you’d want to read a book about how all of it got made.
I am one. I’ve watched them all several times. I’ve read a bunch of books about Twin Peaks. I even started a little side blog about Twin Peaks when I watched The Return in 2018. So, yeah, this book is very much my cup of coffee.
There’s no shortage of Twin Peaks material out there. The culty fanbase has had thirty years to produce books, fanzines, blogs, podcasts, videos and more. So it’s hard to add something new to that, but Meslow manages to do it.
First, A Place Both Wonderful and Strange is holistic. It covers the original series, Fire Walk with Me, and, crucially, The Return. That last part makes a huge difference. So much has been written about the original phenomenon of Twin Peaks that it can be hard to find anything genuinely new to say about those first two seasons. By covering the entire strange life of the thing, the book gets to tell a much bigger and more satisfying story.
Second is the access. Meslow talked to Mark Frost and a long list of people who were involved in making the show, and those voices give the book much of its value. It isn’t another attempt to decode what Twin Peaks “means.” There’s some analysis, and some discussion of the mysteries and fan theories, but the book is much more interested in how this deeply weird thing actually got made: the creative decisions, production problems, network fights, personalities, accidents, limitations and occasional flashes of inspiration that produced what ended up on screen.
Finally, the balance is just right. Meslow gives us enough plot to remind us and provide context but resists turning the book into an episode-by-episode recap. Books that do that aren’t necessarily bad, but much of the content becomes a recap of what we can watch. Meslow instead gives us just enough of the what, but then focuses mostly on the why. Why certain decisions were made, how Lynch’s and Frost’s visions came together, how the realities of television production shaped the story, and occasionally how those realities nearly tore the whole thing apart.

The deeper the book gets into the production itself, the more interesting it becomes, particularly in its account of the show’s battles with the network. We get some great stories of Lynch and Frost writing their way around obstacles, and an inside look at their uncanny but phenomenal partnership—Lynch a pure surrealist and Frost a disciplined storyteller.

The other aspect is the focus on the fan reaction, how much of a cultural phenomenon the show was, and the pressure that caused the network to place on Lynch and Frost. The network’s insistence that the show reveal who killed Laura Palmer remains one of the great examples of television executives getting exactly what they asked for and discovering that they probably shouldn’t have asked for it. The mystery was the engine of the show. Once the killer was revealed, Twin Peaks suddenly had to figure out what it was about, and for a while the answer seemed to be: about twelve different things.
If I have a criticism of the book, it’s that Meslow is too easy on season 2. The behind-the-scenes look helps explain why it feels so uneven, with some incredible episodes but then plenty of pointless side plots, cringe humor, and weird for the sake of weird. The network jerked the show around. Scheduling was a mess. There were creative and production problems. And whenever Lynch stepped away to focus on other projects, the show went wonky and we got a knock-off version of the inimitable Lynch. All that context is valuable, and the book does a good job explaining it. But parts of season two are also just inexcusably bad.
This is clearly a heavily researched book, but the tone and energy are from a fan’s point of view. It’s ultimately a celebration of the show, particularly when it reaches The Return. It’s hard to overstate what an achievement The Return was. A television series disappears, becomes a cult object for decades, and then 25 years later actually comes back—after having planted the line “I’ll see you again in 25 years” in the original show. And what comes back isn’t some safe nostalgia exercise. Frost talks about how he stepped back a little and told Lynch that this was his opportunity to really let it rip.
The result is 18 hours of uncompromising, unsettling, baffling, occasionally hilarious, sometimes horrifying weirdness. Surreal and dreamlike, like David Lynch was melted down into a liquid and injected right into your eyeballs.

More than anything else, A Place Both Wonderful and Strange reminded me how unlikely the whole Twin Peaks story is. The original series shouldn’t have worked on network television. Fire Walk with Me shouldn’t have existed in the form it did. And The Return certainly shouldn’t have happened 25 years later. And yet all of it exists.
It’s all just so frickin’ special.
If you’re not a fan of the show, I don’t know why you’re still reading this. But if you did make it this far, this book is a very enjoyable read, and an excellent excuse to go back to Twin Peaks.